MJB Law We Can Help

The Enforcement Process of the LCLB

Date: May 19 2015
Author: Dennis Coates QC

The current process overview:

The Liquor Control Licensing Branch (LCLB) website has some excellent material as background to understanding the enforcement process including articles on the Enforcement Process, Enforcement Hearing Rules, Annual Reports on the Minors as Agents Program (MAP) and copies of decisions of the adjudicators hearing the disputed allegations.

Contraventions, which look like a normal ticket, get issued either after a visit by a Branch inspector or after an incident or accident, particularly if the circumstances involve the RCMP. The receipt of the contravention should trigger a process by the licensee to gather the facts around the alleged contravention, including getting written statements from employees who were working at the time, preserving a video if one exists and generally determining what occurred on the premises at the time of the alleged offense.

The next step, if the Branch considers it should proceed to an enforcement hearing, is that a Notice of Enforcement Hearing (NOEA) will be mailed to the licensee. At that point decision as to what the licensee should do, is required. The licensee must either sign a waiver and accept the suggested penalty or dispute either the offence, the penalty or both. The LCLB will request a decision fairly quickly.

A prehearing telephone conference will be scheduled. At such time, disclosure of witnesses, determination of length of hearing and date for hearing will be decided. The licensee has the option to sign a waiver at any time, up until the time of the scheduled hearing.

My advice is there is no real rush to make a decision. Assume you are defending the allegations. You can change your position if necessary later.

The factors which determine whether a waiver should be signed:

The Liquor Policy Review has directed that a new process for determining disputes, on enforcement and other matters, may be appropriate.

Until 2002, a body known as the Liquor Appeal Board existed where appeals could be taken from decisions of the LCLB. It was a body independent of the LCLB, and a body where licensees could represent themselves. The current system has no independent adjudicator, as the adjudicator is an appointment of the General Manager of the LCLB, paid by the LCLB and part of the LCLB. This does not imply that the current adjudicators do not act independently, but the current process does not have an independent review of Branch decisions and actions.

In dealing with current problems, it may be advantageous to try and wait for the new adjudication system to be implemented later this year. An appeal of a current decision requires a Judicial Review in Supreme Court. This requires legal help and is very expensive – usually $15,000 or  more in legal fees – which make it too expensive and too time consuming for most licensees. Also, the LCLB has a current policy that they will not deal with any licensing issues while an appeal or hearing process is underway, which at times, forces licensees to capitulate and sign a waiver even if there is a proper defense. For example, ownership transfers, capacity changes, etc.

The severity of the penalty for a second offence may dictate that a licensee must defend an enforcement action. As an example, on the first offense, the common penalty for a minor in an Licensee Retail Store (LRS) under the MAP initiative is $7,500 and often the fine will be paid rather than pay legal fees and use valuable time.

The real concern, which I think will be alleviated by changes coming out of the Liquor Policy Review process, is the penalty for a second offence. In this case, on a secondary offense, there is no option for a monetary fine, and the range of days of closure is 20 to 30, which could do permanent damage to an LRS business. There must be a one year gap from the first offence, to not trigger the higher penalty of the second offence.

The 2013/14 LCLB MAP report indicates there were 130 MAP inspections in LRS’s, and a total of 253 in all categories of licenses, and 70 cases of sales to minors.

In summary, when a licensee is deciding whether to sign a waiver, the important issues are:

  1. severity of a second offense penalty
  2. likelihood of a real defense
  3. cost
  4. other pending licensing issues

Preparation for a hearing and decision to defend an alleged infraction:

The normal available defence is that of due diligence; which in general terms, means that a licensee must show that it was duly diligent in taking reasonable steps to ensure that the contravention would not occur. This involves procedures such as staff training, staff meetings and licensee policy and operational manuals, which should normally prevent the infraction from occurring. The licensee must demonstrate that the procedures are continually acted upon and that any problems are reacted to, to prevent infractions. There are three cases I would recommend reading to fully understand the degree of due diligence required. These are available on the LCLB web site:

  • Beverly Liquor Store Ltd. – Dec 7, 2012
  • Rayman Investments & Management Inc. – Jan 23, 2013
  • Irish Times Pub Co. Ltd. – April 16, 2014

The cases first comment on the issue of who is the directing mind of the licensee – this is important because if the owner or the general manager of the licensee was present or involved, at the time of the alleged incident, the due diligence defence is not available. Normally an employee would not be the directing mind of the licensee.

The adjudicator will determine, from the facts, whether there was adequate training and systems in place to prevent the contravention and whether the licensee had taken reasonable steps to ensure that the training and systems were effective.

The test is not perfection. A read of these cases will give you a guide as to whether your due diligence processes and procedures are adequate. Often they are not. The processes and procedures need to be documented in staff training manuals, regular meeting minutes with employees and constant reminders related to matters such as ID processes for minors.

Often due diligence is described, when adequate, as a culture of compliance. Often the facts of the alleged contravention are not in dispute, such as sale to a minor. A licensee may need assistance at the time of the issuance of the NOEA, and in preparing for the enforcement hearing. Legal help is not always necessary but proper preparation for the hearing is essential.

The hearings are not recorded, as a matter of course. However, if there is a possibility that the licensee may proceed to a Judicial Review process, if the adjudicator’s decision is unfavourable, a court reporter should attend. The licensee would have to arrange this.

popular personal essay writers for hire usa buy astronomy presentation write my religious studies thesis statement help me write professional phd essay on trump esl dissertation results writing for hire best custom essay ghostwriter for hire for college best admission essay writers service au professional dissertation hypothesis proofreading services for college professional masters blog post topic custom academic essay editor for hire for mba top curriculum vitae editing service au help with my custom critical thinking online pay to write cheap admission essay best blog post writing services cheap paper ghostwriters services for university professional homework writer website gb top dissertation hypothesis editing services uk custom essay ghostwriter for hire for university esl problem solving editor site us type my classic english literature report help me write custom reflective essay esl critical analysis essay proofreading for hire ca cheap curriculum vitae ghostwriting site us best reflective essay ghostwriters websites for mba top dissertation hypothesis editor sites usa cheap content editing for hire for college popular report ghostwriting services usa popular admission essay editor services usa descriptive essay writer site uk custom dissertation abstract editing sites cheap research proposal editing service usa best school essay writers service online cheap college cheap essay advice buy english report professional blog editor website for masters professional dissertation ghostwriting websites online esl case study ghostwriting service us pay to do top problem solving online cheap critical analysis essay proofreading sites for college cheap article review ghostwriters sites uk soft shell lobster top article ghostwriting websites au custom creative essay writing service gb popular blog post ghostwriter site for university top expository essay writers websites custom university essay editing sites for university cheap mba admission essay ideas do my human resource management creative writing dissertation ghostwriter websites au professional speech editor websites for masters best writing service online esl analysis essay writer website uk professional school homework assistance best dissertation methodology writing for hire for phd best literature review ghostwriting websites for phd popular application letter writing websites for college esl letter writer website gb top definition essay writer site best creative writing writers sites online popular biography editor sites for university culture essay writing for hire best cover letter ghostwriter website for mba top presentation ghostwriting services usa professional dissertation methodology proofreading services for college esl blog post writers sites for masters esl speech editor website usa popular university essay ghostwriting sites for phd professional dissertation methodology writers websites for masters cheap papers writing service gb top papers writer sites for phd esl descriptive essay editor sites for university top home work writer website for university top dissertation results editing service for mba popular thesis proposal writers for hire online cheap definition essay ghostwriter services usa professional scholarship essay editor site us esl bibliography editing site online type my family and consumer science curriculum vitae cheap expository essay proofreading for hire critical analysis essay proofreading services au law essay sample top personal statement editor site buy professional letter top academic essay ghostwriters service for school popular blog ghostwriters sites us best mba essay writer sites ca reflective essay for university write my engineering application letter cheap masters essay writers services for mba professional presentation ghostwriter website ca ancient egyptian paper best admission essay writing websites for university custom thesis writer for hire us custom reflective essay ghostwriter service for school popular college essay ghostwriter site online custom definition essay writing for hire gb write environmental studies bibliography popular essays ghostwriter site uk cheap assignment ghostwriters service for mba custom paper writing sites gb pay to write admission essay on lincoln professional personal statement proofreading websites for masters cheap scholarship essay writing sites ca top content ghostwriting service gb popular analysis essay editing website online esl report writing service for mba help with my ancient civilizations dissertation chapter top problem solving ghostwriters site online popular course work ghostwriters website for university best definition essay ghostwriter site for university cheap analysis essay writer service for school help with trigonometry dissertation methodology custom editor service for masters preschool child observation report pay to do communication term paper pay to do health course work popular essays ghostwriting for hire online esl thesis proposal writing websites for mba type my top best essay professional research paper ghostwriter service usa professional research proposal proofreading service esl dissertation proposal ghostwriter service for university popular creative writing ghostwriter websites ca best blog ghostwriting site for college best content writer service gb professional presentation ghostwriting site uk esl university dissertation chapter example popular mba essay writers sites online popular dissertation introduction ghostwriters site au liberal view on poverty order top scholarship essay on usa top scholarship essay proofreading service ca top annotated bibliography writers for hire for phd cheap mba dissertation methodology examples the buried life summary popular argumentative essay writer sites for masters best research proposal editor sites for phd professional research proposal proofreading websites usa top papers editor sites uk esl biography proofreading service us cheap college cover letter samples popular college creative writing examples pay for custom problem solving online personal proofreading service au custom dissertation abstract writers websites online cheap research paper writing site online best bibliography editing services gb hamlet comic relief top university biography topics top scholarship essay writers website gb esl term paper editor website for masters top term paper ghostwriters services us esl admission essay writers for hire for university personal statement editor for hire online top blog writers site au cheap paper editing services for college business essay writer sites top speech editing for hire us pay for my custom reflective essay on donald trump cheap dissertation chapter writers websites for school professional report ghostwriter service for college best admission paper ghostwriting services for masters custom blog editor site for mba julius caesar paper help with my esl persuasive essay on civil war custom thesis writing service for university custom scholarship essay writer services ca a seperate peace theme write esl expository essay on usa community identity stability best movie review ghostwriters sites for university custom article review editing websites for school pay for professional rhetorical analysis essay on brexit community essay sample top resume ghostwriting site for phd esl article review writing services ca best book review proofreading website for mba custom thesis writing site au popular admission paper ghostwriter website au best book review editing websites usa cheap homework editor website for university cheap cover letter writer websites for mba just lather esl university academic essay example esl paper editing services ca best university cv example pay to write popular admission essay on lincoln professional research paper editing sites online top case study ghostwriter site for college top speech ghostwriting website for mba professional speech writing website for university custom course work proofreading for hire for college professional dissertation methodology editor for hire for masters popular rhetorical analysis essay proofreading service au critical essay ghostwriting for hire uk help with my esl custom essay on usa popular dissertation hypothesis ghostwriter for hire for mba best thesis ghostwriters service for mba pros of racial profiling custom critical analysis essay ghostwriting site usa pay to get phd essay on usa cheap cv ghostwriters for hire usa esl research proposal ghostwriting service gb write me esl book review esl best essay proofreading site help me write shakespeare studies cover letter help me write best critical essay on presidential elections professional cv ghostwriting sites for mba write my best bibliography online best masters thesis advice top analysis essay writers website for university website review essay best analysis essay writer site for university pay for my professional creative essay on presidential elections custom content writing sites au best reflective essay ghostwriting for hire usa professional curriculum vitae editor website au esl dissertation chapter writer websites usa custom phd biography topic cheap phd curriculum vitae advice popular book review ghostwriter service for university write top business plan online blog ghostwriters sites online esl university assignment sample custom essays ghostwriters for hire for school custom essay ghostwriters service top persuasive essay ghostwriting service for school custom reflective essay editor websites ca top academic essay writers service for phd best writer site au professional dissertation proposal writers service for college top admission essay editor for hire for school best dissertation results editor service for mba popular rhetorical analysis essay editor site au cheap phd essay ghostwriters website for university custom scholarship essay writing service usa blog post ghostwriters service au best phd essay ghostwriter website for school cheap biography writers website us custom argumentative essay proofreading websites for mba cheap mba business plan topics help writing life science thesis write medicine letter popular academic essay ghostwriting services au pay to do popular phd essay on presidential elections professional admission paper ghostwriting for hire gb professional content writers sites for school help me write best masters essay on lincoln esl course work ghostwriter site uk popular article ghostwriter for hire for phd custom critical essay ghostwriting sites uk scholarship editor website usa mom is best popular blog post ghostwriter sites au cheap academic essay writer service au cheap scholarship essay writers services au cheap dissertation writing for hire usa top thesis proposal ghostwriter service gb professional academic essay ghostwriting service for university dissertation abstract writing for hire gb popular content writer website au esl annotated bibliography writers website uk best critical analysis essay writers services for university custom dissertation results editing websites for masters love in la sparknotes top biography writing for hire uk best academic essay ghostwriters site for university top report ghostwriters service for college popular dissertation introduction writer services for masters professional best essay editor services us popular article review ghostwriters services for college custom personal essay on usa custom thesis proposal ghostwriters websites for mba top annotated bibliography proofreading service for university best critical analysis essay writing website ca popular dissertation abstract ghostwriting services us popular blog writing websites best school essay writing sites for masters pay to write art & architecture bibliography top research paper writers website for phd top literature review ghostwriter website gb cheap college movie review socialization and culture top letter editing site au top dissertation results writers sites for school popular cv editing site for university popular thesis writing websites au best creative essay ghostwriting service online cheap literature review editor site au custom college course work example help me write popular creative essay on hacking top academic essay ghostwriter service best critical thinking editor website us professional masters expository essay help best rhetorical analysis essay ghostwriting services uk popular expository essay writer service for school professional homework proofreading website for mba cheap article editing site for college popular school cv examples logic essay ghostwriting site professional mba dissertation proposal esl dissertation ghostwriter services for phd phd essay on history best dissertation methodology ghostwriter website au popular book review proofreading site for university popular course work ghostwriter website usa cheap creative essay ghostwriting for hire for phd esl creative writing writing for hire for school elvis presleys wife cheap dissertation hypothesis ghostwriting for hire for university what are western religions top blog ghostwriting sites ca help writing best analysis essay on hillary cheap dissertation proposal writing for hire au help with custom admission paper buy shakespeare studies thesis top critical essay editor service online esl expository essay writers site custom personal essay editor service for school popular blog ghostwriter sites au type my professional critical essay on shakespeare custom persuasive essay writing sites us esl paper editing site us pay to write health speech cheap essays writers website usa esl university essay ghostwriting website for phd cheap best essay writer services gb cheap scholarship essay proofreading website for phd help with best literature review online custom creative writing writers service au professional annotated bibliography ghostwriter services ca dissertation chapter ghostwriter sites us professional dissertation proposal writer website for mba literature review writers services ca order classic english literature resume persuasive editor services us popular best essay writing for hire for university rhetorical analysis ghostwriter websites au top curriculum vitae proofreading service gb professional research proposal proofreading site for masters popular business plan ghostwriting site for college custom university essay ghostwriting website for mba type my women and gender studies creative writing best mba essay ghostwriters for hire us cheap phd essay ghostwriter service best dissertation abstract ghostwriting website for phd esl speech proofreading sites for school custom argumentative essay editing site for mba custom school letter assistance best dissertation conclusion editor websites for phd do my custom masters essay on shakespeare esl curriculum vitae editor service custom academic essay writing for hire au type my custom academic essay on usa professional critical thinking ghostwriters site for masters esl book review writers websites au professional creative essay ghostwriter websites for university pay to write investments admission essay physics writing websites top critical thinking writers sites ca case study ghostwriter site ca professional presentation ghostwriter site for school cheap argumentative essay editor websites for school popular course work ghostwriters website uk top course work ghostwriter service for school help writing statistics dissertation conclusion popular personal essay writing services online life science essay writers for hire custom thesis proposal writer services uk esl bibliography ghostwriting service cheap university business plan topic best dissertation results editor service ca cheap curriculum vitae editor sites for school best biography editor website au professional argumentative essay writing service top book review writer websites for school popular dissertation ghostwriter site usa custom phd essay ghostwriter website top college essay ghostwriter site online esl blog ghostwriter websites online best best essay writers services us buy logic cover letter professional scholarship essay ghostwriting for hire for university help writing film studies cv esl proofreading website au pay for tourism bibliography top annotated bibliography writing website uk business analysis paper popular rhetorical analysis essay writing websites for phd an image of africa meaning of true friendship cheap cover letter ghostwriters services popular dissertation ghostwriters site usa write me ancient civilizations movie review order world literature book review professional admission essay proofreading website uk popular course work ghostwriter sites for university biography proofreading for hire online ahab in moby dick nature vs nurture research paper custom college dissertation ideas cheap school annotated bibliography advice best course work ghostwriter for hire uk esl article review editing for hire for mba custom definition essay writing site for phd pay to write anthropology article review professional phd dissertation sample cheap book review writer websites custom dissertation results ghostwriter for hire us pay to write communication book review popular article ghostwriter sites online esl speech proofreading website for phd cheap essays writers services au professional masters essay ghostwriting service for phd top business plan writing services for university best curriculum vitae writing website au professional university admission essay advice popular expository essay ghostwriter websites pay to get theater studies dissertation results popular custom essay ghostwriter website for masters custom application letter editing websites for college symbols in the metamorphosis professional thesis proposal ghostwriter service for school popular mba term paper topic breathing underwater sparknotes great depression essay introduction earth science ghostwriters sites cheap personal statement writing services for college custom speech ghostwriting website us dissertation writing services gb popular home work ghostwriters services usa custom descriptive essay writing websites usa professional blog post writers sites for mba popular letter proofreading services for college pay to write custom academic essay on usa best blog editing sites for phd esl admission paper proofreading services uk professional dissertation chapter ghostwriting websites for masters cheap university essay ghostwriter site au custom papers editing site for mba top university essay proofreading website ca help with top dissertation conclusion esl dissertation conclusion editor site au popular blog post writer site for masters esl scholarship essay writers services custom business plan ghostwriter website online esl essays proofreading for hire for mba professional thesis statement writer site uk best article ghostwriters sites ca united methodist communion order earth science admission essay professional personal statement proofreading service for school custom problem solving writers services for school professional homework ghostwriter website ca college ghostwriting websites au logic writing site popular best essay editor services au cheap bibliography ghostwriter for hire uk best report editor site au cheap thesis proofreading site gb professional thesis statement ghostwriter services gb my personal philosophy professional report editing service for university custom ghostwriters website for masters popular scholarship essay proofreading sites usa help me write top blog online top thesis statement writer websites for university cheap assignment ghostwriter services top research paper proofreading site for college cheap research proposal ghostwriter websites online best academic essay proofreading services au pay to get english dissertation hypothesis cheap dissertation abstract ghostwriters sites professional phd resume assistance help with music thesis proposal buy human resource management admission paper professional blog post writer for hire ca best college curriculum vitae samples esl paper ghostwriter service best best essay writing for hire for phd write me best analysis essay online cheap application letter writer sites for mba custom rhetorical analysis essay editing site for college professional problem solving proofreading service for phd esl blog post editing site au reflective editing sites usa esl dissertation conclusion proofreading sites au help with my music home work communication writers services professional phd dissertation hypothesis advice help with my top masters essay on hacking best term paper ghostwriter service for school cheap curriculum vitae editing sites for mba pay to do popular school essay on trump help me write esl university essay on brexit custom research paper writing website gb esl academic essay proofreading for hire top argumentative essay writing services usa popular argumentative essay proofreading for hire for university pay to do history annotated bibliography